Replacing your garage door can significantly impact the appearance, energy efficiency, and safety of your home. If your garage door is old, damaged, or requires frequent repairs, it may be time to consider a replacement. However, before diving into this project, it’s important to understand the factors contributing to garage door replacement costs.

Garage Door Replacement vs Repair

Before deciding to replace your garage door, evaluating whether a repair would suffice is essential. While well-maintained garage doors can last for decades, there are certain situations where a replacement becomes necessary. Mallory Micetich, a home care expert at Angi, suggests considering the following factors when making a decision:

Factors Affecting Garage Door Replacement Cost

The cost of garage door replacement can vary depending on several factors. According to Micetich, the primary contributors to the overall cost are materials and labor. Additionally, the garage door’s size, material, style, insulation, and customizations also impact the final price.

For instance, single-car garages typically cost around $1,000, while two-car garages can cost closer to $1,200. Labor costs, which include installation, can add approximately $300 to the total. When budgeting for the project, it’s important to consider your location, as areas with a high cost of living or limited access to garage installers may incur higher costs.

Professional garage door installers usually price garage door replacements as a complete project, encompassing the door, labor, tracks, and hardware. The design and material choice may influence the cost but won’t affect the duration of the job or the required labor. Additionally, obtaining permits may be necessary if structural changes or electrical installations are involved. Homeowners living in neighborhoods with homeowners associations might also face specific material and design requirements.

Types of Garage Doors

Homeowners have various options for selecting a garage door type and the material it’s made from. Micetich highlights that styles are available to suit every budget, ranging from affordable standard panel or roll-up doors to luxury carriage doors. Here’s a breakdown of the average costs for different garage door styles according to HomeAdvisor:

Type Description Cost Range Average
Standard panel A single-panel garage door that folds when it slides up. $300-$800 $550
Tilt-up A single-panel door that protrudes forward when it slides up. Can also be used as a canopy. $500-$1,200 $850
Roll-up Made of multiple horizontal sheets that roll up at the top of the garage. $400-$1,500 $950
Glass roll-up Made of multiple glass and aluminum panels that fold up. Offers good insulation but is expensive. $700-$6,900 $3,800
French doors Opens outward, similar to interior French doors. Often made of wood and suitable for country-style architecture. $2,000-$5,500 $3,750
Walk-through Garage doors with a pedestrian door installed within them. $700-$5,000+ $2,850
Carriage doors Luxury garage doors that swing in and out. Often made of wood with glass windows. $1,000-$10,000 $5,500

The choice of material and design also significantly affects the overall garage door replacement costs. Here are the approximate costs of common garage door materials based on HomeAdvisor:

It’s important to consider the maintenance and repair costs associated with different materials, as some may require more attention and upkeep over the years.

Manual vs. Automatic Garage Doors

Manual garage door replacement costs are generally cheaper to install compared to automatic ones. The average cost to install a manual garage door ranges from $600 to $2,150. If you decide to automate the door, expect to pay an additional $200 to $1,300.

Hiring Professionals vs. DIY

Garage door installation is a labor-intensive and potentially dangerous task. Unless you have garage door installation experience, hiring a professional is recommended. Mishandling heavy doors, improper track installation, incorrect winding of springs, or misalignment of the opener can lead to accidents and damage to your property. To ensure the job is done correctly and to avoid harm to yourself, your house, or your new garage door, it’s best to bring in a professional.


When considering a garage door replacement, it’s crucial to take into account various factors that influence the cost. Assessing the extent of damage, the age of the existing garage door, operational difficulties, safety concerns, energy efficiency, and curb appeal can help determine whether a replacement is necessary. The cost of materials, labor, size, style, insulation, and customizations also contribute to the overall expense. By understanding these factors, homeowners can make informed decisions and budget effectively for their garage door replacement project.

Discover more from North Haven Overhead Door Co. LLC.

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading